Yeah I think that’s definitely something beehaw gets right. It noticeably alters the tone of conversations when people can’t just downvote everything they don’t like. Kbin’s making votes public I think helps somewhat though.
Former landed gentry.
Yeah I think that’s definitely something beehaw gets right. It noticeably alters the tone of conversations when people can’t just downvote everything they don’t like. Kbin’s making votes public I think helps somewhat though.
I don’t think karma should ever be visible for any reason and downvotes should be disabled. But I know that is not a very popular opinion. “Karma” should only be in the background, and for the purposes of moderation/admin needs (such as thresholds). Downvotes invariably become disagree buttons, and net karma doesn’t really mean anything other than someone has been on a long time.
Yeah, this is what I was about to write. As long as they can all talk to each other, who cares? They used to be like a dozen popular email clients. It didn’t really create any issues (for the end user at least)
I mean, what are they gonna do? Pull the VERY loyal people from kbin.social or Lemmy.world into Threads? Or the people from Mastodon?
No. What they will do is follow the activity pub protocol, then make their own tweaks that all the other instances are supposed to follow (despite being closed off tweaks), or we are no longer interacting with them. Eventually our open source standard is overshadowed by their new partially proprietary standard, they have 95% of the users and more functionality so they have no reason to leave, and we are the ones who are doing it wrong. Then we are extinguished and they begin the process of enshitification/extracting every cent possible.
i.e. embrace, extend, extinguish.
It’s not that we don’t believe in it. It’s that we literally went through this already. And now we expect meta to be more magnanimous than google?
Fool me once and all that. I was with you at one point but after Reddit’s bullshit this past summer the glass broke for me. I don’t need 1 billion people here. I’m perfectly content with a small corner of the internet. No control necessary.
If, and this is a big if, it can support an RSS feed that also allows you to provide the requisite info apple et al demand (3000x3000 pixel image, categories, etc.) then it could in theory support it. The bigger concern is traffic - will they be cool with you syndicating out and having folks pulling that frequently and can it support a lot of folks with larger shows doing it. Some podcatchers won’t care and will let you just use an RSS pointing at the page hosting the files, but it’s not a given especially with the larger ones.
My advice? Unless you want to really hack it together yourself and accept that it could force you to migrate without any notice, sure give it a shot. If you are risk averse, don’t want to disrupt your listeners, aren’t really comfortable doing a lot of tech troubleshooting, etc. I’d say don’t try it. Podcast hosting is trivially inexpensive and all the big services have an embeddable player now if you really want folks to listen on your site.
Edit: worth noting that a lot of this is going to depend on whether an instance admin specifically wants to deal with all your traffic, assuming you get regular users/the numbers are decently high. If you stand up your own instance then it’s all about what your infrastructure can support.
deleted by creator
Can we not like, do that Reddit thing at every turn where a certain topic/title always makes it to the top and everybody just duplicates it even though the exact same conversation happens every time?