That is a known bug at the moment. I believe there is a fix in review right now but Codeberg seems to be down.

Search for a community just like you would elsewhere.

This place would be @fediverse@kbin.social, so you’d search that to find this place on the fediverse. Lemmy communities use the same format.

Lemmy doesn’t have the functionality like Kbin does. It’s one reason why Kbin exists.

(Continued from parent due to post length constraints.)

You say we should move off-site. There’s already a large general-purpose forum for Disney: MiceChat. It’s a classic non-federated forum, from a bygone age of the internet. People who aren’t attached to a Reddit-like interface typically are on MiceChat, or one of the thousands of Disney Facebook groups. They’re the largest Disney community on the internet.

We discussed running our own Disney-themed Kbin instance (like /r/StarTrek and /r/Android both did), that would be a federated competitor to MiceChat. The idea still appeals to me. But the fact of the matter is that we didn’t have the time nor money to be admins. I have a full-time job where I can’t be spending time working as an admin all day (and - fun fact - I actually did work for Disney, formerly), and I don’t have the legal know-how to host a website.

Making a community on someone else’s instance doesn’t have those same issues. kbin.social has a sane admin team and is permissive with federation, giving the magazine a large reach (but keeping out hate speech and trolls). There are people on here who want to participate in their hobbies - like going to Disneyland, which for many is a hobby - or who want to use the community as a resource (and the Disneyland subreddit was a resource, too).

Because at the end of the day - it is a lot of work, but seeing a thriving community is rewarding. You grow attached to it. It’s why people play simulation games; you help shepard people along, make people happy, and watch the line go up. It’s not “ego” any more than playing a city builder game is “ego”. I certainly never threw my weight around on Reddit; our subreddit was positively tiny compared to others. The only time I used my green badge on Reddit was to give people warnings or make community-wide announcements. The only time I mentioned I was a mod elsewhere was when I needed a “fun fact” to introduce myself with at work/school or when it’s directly relevant (like letting people on the fediverse know that the magazine here is run by the same team that ran it on Reddit).

The Disneyland subreddit was a good community, IMO. The whole mod team did a lot of work to keep it good, and I was proud to help out. Connecting people with the resources they need and letting them show off the things that made them excited, while keeping the spambots and trolls at bay and redirecting lost folks to the right spot. It’s something you need to experience to understand.

One thing that was missing was Disney’s direct involvement. Disney never contacted us. Even when I worked for them - corporate knew I was a mod there but left us alone since it was considered my personal business (my only restriction was that I couldn’t say I was speaking officially on behalf of the company). As long as the sidebar said that we were fan-run, Disney never said a peep. Because Disney didn’t have any official presence on Reddit, folks would frequently repost news shared by Disney to the subreddit directly.

Threads gives us a unique opportunity to be able to connect folks to official Disney social media right here on Kbin. They’d be able to interact 2-way without needing to make a Threads account themselves (and without Disney needing to come here officially). It’s really the best thing that could happen for that type of community, and it would be a shame to lose out on it.

I am using “my magazine” as a colloquial term for “the magazine I moderate”, obviously not as the term for “the magazine I own”. I trust you know that and are arguing in bad faith.

You can go start your own magazine on another instance if you wish. The presence of one does not preclude competition. Heck, you can even start another one here; we had similar subreddits on Reddit. The /r/WaltDisneyWorld folks were an example of a bad mod team on a power trip, which caused splinter subreddits to pop up like /r/DisneyWorld. The /r/WaltDisneyWorld mod team came here to Kbin and sure enough Kbin has already splintered too - there’s @WaltDisneyWorld (original WaltDisneyWorld mods), @DisneyWorld, and @wdw.

If you think you can do a good job running a Disneyland magazine, I’m not going to stop you from making DisneylandResort or DisneyParks or going to Lemmy and making something there. Competition is good and healthy.

But… I don’t think you truly appreciate how much work moderating a community can be. I literally was a mod for 1 sizeable subreddit (I was a mod on 2-3 other subs, technically, but they had subscriber counts in the dozens and rarely saw activity).

I’d love to show you what moderating a subreddit with 500k subscribers really looks like. It gets bad. Gore, scat, porn, hate, bigotry, and trolling - you deal with it all. Death threats in modmail to boot. And we were just 500k subs! The former default subs have millions and they are far worse, I’ve been told.

We ran a community for folks to discuss a single topic: the Disneyland Resort in Anaheim, CA. Not Hong Kong Disneyland, not Disneyland Paris, not Walt Disney World. Those have their own subreddits, with their own communities and their own mod team (plus /r/disneyparks). I wasn’t associated with any of them outside of small formalities; I only got to know them during the blackout when we did look into coordinating our own site. (More on that later.)

If each mod team didn’t do their job, each sub would be overrun with posts that don’t fit the sub. We’re constantly removing posts about WDW or Disneyland Paris or Shanghai Disneyland or whatever. We’re constantly removing posts from people talking about general Disney stuff that doesn’t have anything to do with the park. It’s a lot of work to curate a feed, and when the effort is made in good faith we redirect people to more appropriate places to talk about the things they’re passionate about.

People joined that subreddit to talk about the Disneyland in Anaheim; many didn’t care about Shanghai Disneyland or whatever. If we missed something and a person posts about the “wrong” park (which happens sometimes, even with AutoMod), the community generally comes in and downvotes the post (and sometimes insults the user). From their perspective, they’re seeing some content they don’t care about/want in their feed. And technically, per Reddiquette, that’s what the downvote button is “supposed” to be for - sorting out things that don’t belong.

It’s like posting a TikTok link to /r/YoutubeHaiku or a picture to /r/videos - each community has a set of rules and a social contract to enforce them. That’s what makes a good community with relevant content that makes you come back. Without a good mod team, a subreddit gets overrun with posts that don’t fit the sub - you can see some of that here on Lemmy/Kbin already. This is both because mod tools are lacking (no AutoMod) and because people are changing instances as they see fit. For example, @Starwars is abandoned, I think - the only(!!!) mod hasn’t been active in weeks. I’ve seen things here like videos in the politics communities and other things that wouldn’t fly with larger mod teams.

(Hit max character length, continued as a reply)

My worry that many articles are going to have a biased take on the situation, or be coming from Mastodon etc. where things don’t map up 1:1.

My perspective:

I moderate a medium-sized magazine here on Kbin (@Disneyland, about 264 subscribers here and a couple dozen elsewhere on the fediverse). You can’t moderate a magazine from another instance, nor can you redirect a magazine somewhere else. This means I effectively must use Kbin.social, especially since I also mod the /r/Disneyland subreddit and have been redirecting people to our magazine for a month now.

I personally would like to see Threads here, if only because @disneyparks would be a nice fit to have automatically included in our microblog tab. I can’t go to another instance that supports Threads because again - moderators on Kbin can’t be from different instances. And besides - me being on another instance doesn’t stop the fact that I couldn’t have content from Threads automatically added here. So my options are basically “deal with it” or “abandon the community here”.

It really sucks that there is a way that could make my magazine better by including actual official Disney sources in our Disney-themed magazine, but some people are afraid of EEE they are trying to keep that from everyone. I’d rather federate with Threads and allow users to individually block the domain if they desire.

• If EEE is the worry, fight them at the “extend” step, not the “embrace” one.

• If mountains of spam is the worry - people have to manually follow people from other instances for those posts to federate to Kbin, so not every single account will magically pop up here on Kbin. It’ll be accounts that people on Kbin have followed; a small chunk.

• Vice-versa, Threads is full of casual users who don’t know much about the fediverse. Any Threads users interacting on Kbin are those who understand the fediverse and go out of their way to subscribe to Kbin magazines from Threads. We know from past history that these are going to be a minority; even within the fediverse, Mastodon is huge (and tech-savvy) but we see very few Mastodon folks posting to Kbin threads.

• If “Facebook is sucking up all my data” is the worry, they could do that anyway. The fediverse is open and public; they can easily set up a “shadow instance” that federates everywhere and slurps everything. They don’t need Threads for that.

If people just don’t want to see Threads users at all, making the block button defederate on the account level would be wonderful. If people choose to block Threads, then Threads users couldn’t see them and vice versa. People who see Threads as a potential useful resource (myself, for the magazine I mod) would still be able to have that content in the community here on Kbin. Everyone’s happy.

I’m aware of the history - I used XMPP myself, for a long long time. I’m mad it’s effectively gone.

Heck, on my Windows Phone once upon a time I could have chats with SMS, Facebook Messenger, and Google Hangouts all without leaving the stock native texting app. One by one they all broke and faded away.

But my point is - is the fedipact a better outcome?

My thought is no, it isn’t. The intention of the fedipact is to split the fediverse in two - the side that federates with corporations, and the side that doesn’t.

But the issue is that in splitting the fediverse when it’s still so young and fragile, you’re going to inherently kill it. Even if people maintain accounts on both sides of the divide, time is finite. People will make a choice to participate in one side of the fediverse or the other, knowingly or not.

My gut tells me people are going to want to go where the network effect is strongest. They’re going to go where they know the people, where Wil Wheaton or Arnold Schwarzenegger might randomly pop up in the replies to a post.

And this is going to cause people to choose the side of the fediverse that gives them that interaction. Some may still choose to stay true to the fedipact - just as people do still use XMPP and IRC - but if the fedipact goes as intended, the fediverse will splinter and most people will go to the side with their friends.

I don’t see how that world where the fedipact is successful is any different than the option 2 you laid out. The fedipact has caused 2 fediverses: one that has lost the network effect and is beginning to decay; the other dominated by a corporation. The fedipact side will have few people left because everyone left to talk to their friends on Meta.

The only way forward is to hope for option 1. Is it foolish? Maybe. Meta is a corporation that wants money. XMPP died a bad death. You can even argue that email is dead as an open protocol now - ever try sending an email message on your own server?

But we can hope for a situation like what we’re seeing with ZigBee/Matter where an open, clear standard is maintained. And maybe that’ll change in a decade, but the only thing the fedipact does is remove any hope for that at all.

Yep, a lot of my old friends and co-workers aren’t on Mastodon. I’m seeing them pop up on Threads.

I really want to be able to follow my friends and interact with my friends and - from my perspective - it’s this vocal minority loudly saying “YOU DON’T NEED TO TALK TO YOUR FRIENDS, LET’S SPLIT THE FEDIVERSE”.

It makes no goddamn sense. If the fedipact holds you’re just going to have two separate fediverses now and users are going to fragment. I’d rather interact with my IRL friends than a bunch of nerds talking to each other on Mastodon about the last time they showered. I get that they’re trying to avoid “embrace, extend, extinguish” but splitting the fediverse into 2 is actively worse.

EEE is all about a corporation making a product that (to an average user) is better than the free alternative, and making it hard for the free alternative to keep up and maintain parity. Over time, people will leave the free version and go to the corpo version and the free version will have nothing on it but diehard nerds.

Defederating from the corpo instances is literally identical. All these people are just going to shoot themselves in the foot. You are giving people the option of “talk to all of your friends and celebrities” or “talk to us, a bunch of overbearing control freaks who jump at shadows”. Of course people are going to choose their friends and leave behind the strangers they hardly know. If the fedipact has its way, Mastodon’s core users will dwindle and dwindle until it’s just the hardcore. Note that this is the exact same outcome as EEE, but Meta didn’t have to lift a finger.

Don’t mistake me for someone who likes Meta, mind. I hate the Zuck. Not as much as I hate Elon, but I do not like Zuckerberg. But I’m given the chance to use FOSS stuff to talk to my friends? I can use apps like Fedilab and swap between Threads and Mastodon? I can follow Threads users from here on Kbin? Threads users can subscribe to my magazines and make posts?

I’d much rather make Facebook work on EEE than do it to ourselves for free.

You’re the one who chose to post it without fixing it yourself to make it readable. ChatGPT didn’t paste it into that box and hit the “add comment” button.

Kbin tags work the same way. Every person you see in the microblog tag is directly followed by someone on Kbin.

I have purposely been going out and following interesting Mastodon accounts from Kbin to ensure that they’re being brought over into the Kbin feed and put into the proper magazines.

@0x1C3B00DA My issue with this proposal as a moderator is how conflicting moderation styles will work. Moderators would either have to do double the work (if everything is sent over) or they may lose out on posts that would be fine in one community but not another (if each community moderates separately).

The only way to fix it would be to “unfollow” the communities and that in turn can cause users to get upset. I think a multireddit approach is probably better TBH.

Beehaw doesn’t allow you to create communities. They were our initial choice until we learned that.

Kbin is against hate speech, which is all I ask for. And we had issues with those users on Reddit regardless; Reddit doesn’t instantly ban someone the moment they spout the n-word across 12 subreddits.

Usually AutoMod catches/removes it, then we ban when reviewing modqueue. (Which the official app doesn’t have last time I checked.) AutoMod doesn’t exist here, which makes that harder… but we’re small enough that it doesn’t matter.

I’ll have to run it by the other mods.

We do have a very aggressive AutoMod with a lot of false positives. We’re about the Disneyland Resort in Anaheim, but people frequently come to ask about Tokyo Disney or Disneyland Paris or Walt Disney World.

That’s the number 1 thing AutoMod catches, but then it also catches people saying something innocent (“XYZ is better at Disneyland than WDW”).

If we turned off AutoMod, we’d quickly become a “generic Disney theme parks” subreddit. I brokered that idea to the mod team before we opened up, but they weren’t completely onboard so we didn’t go through with it.

Yes, that’s the plan. We have it at the top of our sidebar, and as a sticky post.

I had an AutoMod that automatically mentioned it everywhere but the other mods asked me to turn that one off as it was a little too invasive.

I’m hoping to also make it an announcement that sticks at the top of the page instead of the AutoMod (the current announcement is stale anyway). But that one is waiting on some of the other mods to sign off.

Ha. They want that stuff they can go to <other subreddit redacted>.

It’s been bad since Trump. COVID was the worst though.

We do have a sticky thread that mentions our Kbin community at the very top.

It’s also at the top of our sidebar, above the rules.

Alright, one point at a time:

It sounds like that you are just not interested in building a new community and rather go back to the ivory tower that is reddit.

If we weren’t interested, we wouldn’t have founded the community. We’re now maintaining two. The Disneyland subreddit links to Kbin in its sidebar. While I’d agree that Reddit is somewhat of an ivory tower, bear in mind that it’s a community we’ve cultivated for years and we have a sense of responsibility for them.

What are you gonna do when Reddit is gonna implement the next thing that would be unbeneficial to the community?

Link here, like we already are. We’ve never participated in “Reddit drama”. The fact that we took a stand as-is was a big step for us. We even committed to “indefinite”, not just 48 hours. It wasn’t effective, and we caved after 110 hours or so. Lessons learned.

But when (not if) Reddit shoots itself in the foot, we can have a community here ready for them. Right now it’s small. To a certain extent, that’s positive… the mod tools on Kbin are lacking. But it’s not like we’re abandoning the community here.

Spez is taking inspiration from Elon. He’s going to do more dumb things. He’s already talked about the dumb things he wants to do. There’ll be other waves of migration, and we want to make sure that anyone who still wants the space they had (but doesn’t want to use Reddit) can have a home.

If you know that the possible new mods are asses, why not call reddits bluff?

Do you think Reddit cares about asshole mod teams? Honestly. Remember, the “new mods” already run a major Disney subreddit. If Reddit cared about them being assholes who regularly wind up on SubredditDrama they would have taken action already.

Also bear in mind that I am one person on a team. There are others who work alongside me that have voices which should be heard and respected. To that extent, a lot of them didn’t want to even risk it. I don’t have the authority (by design) to unilaterally override them.

Sorry to say but most of the community does not give a damn about moderators.

…

I thought and still think it would be absolutely ridiculous to invest your time and efforts for a profit making company for absolutely nothing in return.

Absolutely correct. We’re the unpaid jannies, the suckers who need to touch grass. That’s not sarcasm, btw - I really do think that. It’s absolutely ridiculous that we do it at all, especially given the amount of abuse we get from… well, basically everyone.

Spez doesn’t care about our users. We know that. Frankly, there are a lot of places on the internet that are run or controlled by those who don’t care about others.

So spaces that do care are important. You can call it posturing, but it’s the truth. If we didn’t care, we would’ve quit a decade ago.

We care about making our community a welcoming space, a little home on the internet. We care about stopping trolls that see the word “Disney” and want to cause as much damage as possible.

It is absolutely ridiculous to care. Because you’re right - the site doesn’t care. We are giving them value and expecting nothing. They depend on us to care, and they treat us any way they want because they know we’re too goddamn soft to let harm come to the communities we try and protect.

But there are people who need these little rest stops. They need a place to post a picture of their Mickey Mouse balloon, or their engagement photo in front of the castle, or their debate about what on earth the writing on some poster says. It makes them happy and there’s a whole blossoming community there, of happy people in a safe space.

What on earth do I even get out of my “posturing” otherwise? A stupid green badge that says “please yell at me?” I don’t even get that badge outside of my sub. I’m not a powermod; /r/Disneyland is the only major sub I mod. The only others I run are teeny tiny, maybe 600 users. We’re not a Reddit partner community that gets wined and dined.

We’re just some stupid, terminally-online folks who need to touch grass. Doing unpaid labor for an abusive place that doesn’t care, promoting a different abusive monopoly of a company that doesn’t care. All to make some little virtual people on the other side of a box (who also hate us) happy.

I’m a mod of /r/Disneyland, and we recreated our sub over here on Kbin ( @Disneyland, https://kbin.social/m/Disneyland).

The issue is that we had 500k subs on Reddit. That sounds like a lot, but in reality it equates to about a dozen posts a day, maybe less.

Over here on Kbin, we almost have 100 subs - and I’m really proud of that! - but 100 subs is basically nothing. A fraction of a percent of people are actually content contributors, and the whole community rests on them. Then combine that with the fact that we’re a niche subject (not some general thing like “video games”) and that impacts what can be contributed.

On top of that, the magazine is fairly empty. Not barren - we have a few posts - but it certainly looks and feels empty. And because it’s empty, nobody wants to post, which means it stays empty.

Compare that to Reddit, which has a very dedicated community for us. Not a massive community, but certainly a passionate one. We care about our community; we’ve stewarded it for years. All of us mods started out as members of that community (the subreddit founder is long gone), and we’re all unpaid volunteers that want to keep that community healthy.

Reddit threatened to take it from us and give it to another mod team for a related Disney subreddit that played along with the admins. The issue is that multiple Disney subreddits have, uh, issues with those mods (which has been the case for years to the point where explaining the history is part of onboarding for a lot of Disney mods).

So the issue was reframed - either we reopen our sub on our terms… or we stick to our guns, force Reddit to remove us, and get replaced by a different mod team. This other team is known to be harsh about banning users for any kind of dissent, they abuse their mod powers to spread anti-vax nonsense all over their “non-political” subreddit, they have multiple subreddit drama threads talking about their actions, they’ve been gunning for all of the Disney subs for years… and they’d immediately jump at the chance to reopen the subreddit we’ve worked hard on so they could run it their way.

When you look at it like that… there’s only one real choice. I hate Reddit, but our community doesn’t deserve that.

I realize saying “we choose to keep our powers for your own good” makes me sound like, oh, I dunno, “landed gentry”… but users don’t see that side of moderation or Reddit drama, and frankly they shouldn’t have to.

So we opened and are taking the abuse. Users are torn between “you caved, scabs” and “told you this was a useless gesture, how dare you take my sub away”. Neither one is great.

But there’s more to it than what appears on the surface, and frankly that’s true across a lot of subs.

I wonder if there’s a Pyongyang community.

…Come to think of it, Lemmygrad probably has one. But I’m not going over there to look.